To be fair, the falling off may be the lens - I can't tell. Basically it seems like there just aren't enough threads engaging. I am using it on a refurbished (by Nikon) Nikon AF-S 55-300 1:4.5-5.6. I have NOT tried any other filter on the lens.I have the same filter in 52mm and have used it on 2 other lenses (18-55 and 55-200) and it seems to engage more than this bigger filter in the longer lens.As long as you get it seated and remember to twist the filter orientation in the direction of tightening the filter it's okay. I got it backwards and ended up unscrewing the filter (which only seems to be less than a full revolution - less that one full thread) and it fell into dry sand. It doesn't look like it got damaged but I just don't enjoy using it because of the high possibility it may fall off again.And, it's hard to get the threads started.Again, I haven't used any other filter on this lens so it could be the lens too, which is more of a question because the lens was refurbished (although the threads don't look bad or as though they'd been truncated somehow).As for the pictures, I used it to effectively remove glare from a water body. It seems to work fine (as does my 52mm which I've used a lot more). No complaints but I may not see differences between this and a B+W anyway. I can certainly see the difference between this and no filter. I'd buy one again. I think the Tiffen's are a great cross between results and price. When I start seeing artifacts maybe I'll spring for a B+W or other brand.

I bought this for my Canon EFS 17-55 mm f/2.8 IS USM. I am still using it on the same lens and is doing a very good job without distorting or altering the images. Great stuff

Excellent product. I rarely write review. This thing added a different dimention to my photography. Bought 58mm filter for my Canon 700D lenses. Perfectly fit on Canon 18-55 mm and Canon 55-250. Applied lence cap on it and it was perfectly fit. Intensity can be adjusted by moving the filter as you do zoom in and out on lens. Nicely polaroid captured on day light. No testing done yet on low light, but expect you dont need to remove it. Packaging waz good, nice cover given. Did not find any cons yet after using it. Strongly recomended. This is one of the premium polaroid filter with multi coatings and with this you dnt need uv filter to purchase again. Got early delivery. Thanks to Amazon

Received both the 18-35 mm and 55-210 mm lenses along with the case, memory card, charger, battery, and carrying strap. Couldn't be more happy with my purchase. This camera is great for aspiring photographers that want to step up from the point and shoot cameras.

AmazonBasics Circular Polarizer Filter- 58 mm is a perfect fit for Canon EF-S 18-55 and 55-250.

Excellent quality pictures. With the 55-255 mm lens pictures of farther away things are excellent as well.The deal was pretty goof Amazon too. Two extra lenses, printer and lens cover for ~$962. Pretty cool.

I needed something more for taking videos, besides my regular 18-55 mm lense. I do interviews and it gives the ability to get a good focus on the subject. Its a STM which doesn't have as much importance to me because I don't have to focus that much. I love it.

Fit well on both canon 18-55 mm and 55-250 mm lens, however I am not able to used the lens cap properly, lens cap is not getting fit nicely on it, so you have to take it out for carrying the lens inside the bag, about the picture quality, shall update soon after using for sometime.