To be fair, the falling off may be the lens - I can't tell. Basically it seems like there just aren't enough threads engaging. I am using it on a refurbished (by Nikon) Nikon AF-S 55-300 1:4.5-5.6. I have NOT tried any other filter on the lens.I have the same filter in 52mm and have used it on 2 other lenses (18-55 and 55-200) and it seems to engage more than this bigger filter in the longer lens.As long as you get it seated and remember to twist the filter orientation in the direction of tightening the filter it's okay. I got it backwards and ended up unscrewing the filter (which only seems to be less than a full revolution - less that one full thread) and it fell into dry sand. It doesn't look like it got damaged but I just don't enjoy using it because of the high possibility it may fall off again.And, it's hard to get the threads started.Again, I haven't used any other filter on this lens so it could be the lens too, which is more of a question because the lens was refurbished (although the threads don't look bad or as though they'd been truncated somehow).As for the pictures, I used it to effectively remove glare from a water body. It seems to work fine (as does my 52mm which I've used a lot more). No complaints but I may not see differences between this and a B+W anyway. I can certainly see the difference between this and no filter. I'd buy one again. I think the Tiffen's are a great cross between results and price. When I start seeing artifacts maybe I'll spring for a B+W or other brand.

Very Nice Circular Polariser (CPL) for beginners. It cuts down reflections magically.The only issue I faced with 58mm filter is that Canon lens cap doesn't fit over it properly due to less number of threads on the outer side. Rest is fine.Using it on Canon 18-55mm EFS kit lens.

I use a Nikon D3100, I bought a Nikon 50mm f/1.8D AF Nikkor Lens. That lens has 58mm threads. I bought the 58mm Tiffen Circular Polarizer filter to use on that lens. At the time of my order it was sold and fulfilled by Amazon. I paid for shipping and received the filter in less than four days. The filter came in a hard plastic box that I use for storing the filter. It looked new and works fine. No filter problems and I give it 5 stars. The only issue is screwing it onto the lens is a bit tricky because you only have half the width to work with but I blame that on my fingers and lack of any real nails. I have noticed that if the filter doesn't go on straight it may make a glare effect but when I see that, I rescrew it on and that takes care of the issue.

The media could not be loaded.

















 There is so much to love about this Urth filter and the Urth brand as a whole. The first thing that I noticed was the beautiful packaging and the tin case that holds the filter along with a cleaning cloth – of all the filters I have owned this is the first one where I don’t want to just throw away the packaging. The metal rim has good weight to it and threads to the lens easily and smoothly. The filter itself seems to have even color across the entire shot. Overall this is a well-built filter.

Great ND filter for the price. No weird color cast. My only complaint is the threads could be better. Have a hard time getting it on my lenses correctly. But once it’s on. It’s a great filter

Got the Gobe Filter Kit 72mm MRC 16-Layer: UV, CPL Polarizer, ND8, ND1000 about a month ago. Since they arrived it's done nothing but rain. Eventually got out to try them and I have to say they did not disappointed. I am very pleased with the the photos as there is no colour cast like I was getting on the cheaper plastic ones. The only slight problem I got was when I knocked the lens and couldn't get the filter off. Easily solved by getting a small knife and running it round the filter where it screws onto the lens, pulls the threads even with no damage to either lens or filter... Happy Days!!

Easy to install, and is compatible with a dust cap. Works well as a variable polerizer filter with the twist of the lens add on. Would be nice if there was a way to gauge if the polarizer was on or off on the attachment. Otherwise a good product.

For still photography this filter provides a very subtle diffusion effect on light sources. What little video I've taken does seem to soften skin with a pleasing effect. The quality of the filter is good for the price point and overall it is up to the standards that I anticipate from Neewer except for the threads. The threads on my filter had trouble getting started and I had to be very careful not to cross thread them. I will definitely make sure that my filter wrenches are available before use.